ANKARA — In a series of impactful decisions published in the Official Gazette, Turkey’s Constitutional Court (AYM) has delivered three major judgments addressing systemic violations of fundamental rights. The rulings touch upon critical legal issues spanning student discipline and the right to education, the procedural obligations of lower courts in social security disputes, and the constitutional protection of public servants seeking long-overdue wage claims.
The top court’s decisions set significant legal precedents that directly impact millions of citizens, ranging from high school students facing administrative sanctions to retirees establishing employment histories and civil servants pursuing unpaid back wages from local authorities.
Penalties Based on Administrative Regulations
The first significant ruling published by the Constitutional Court centers on the constitutional guarantee of the right to education, set forth under Article 42 of the Turkish Constitution. The court examined individual applications filed on behalf of two high school students, identified in judicial records as R.N.D. and M.R., who were enrolled in separate private secondary education institutions when they were subjected to severe disciplinary measures.
In 2024, R.N.D. was subjected to a mandatory school transfer penalty following allegations of committing verbal attacks and making threats against school administrators and teaching staff. In a separate incident in 2023, M.R. was penalized with the same measure of forced school transfer after school authorities determined that the student had used threatening and insulting language directed at a peer in social media posts.
Both students, through their legal representatives, initiated lawsuits in local administrative courts seeking the formal annulment of the disciplinary sanctions. They argued that the penalties were unlawful and disproportionate. At the time of the incidents, the administrative sanctions were imposed based on provisions contained within the Ministry of National Education High School Regulation (Milli Eğitim Bakanlığı Ortaöğretim Kurumları Yönetmeliği).

The lower administrative courts subsequently dismissed the annulment lawsuits, upholding the actions taken by the educational institutions. Having exhausted all domestic statutory remedies, both students submitted individual applications to the Constitutional Court, asserting that their constitutional right to education had been unconstitutionally infringed upon.
Upon reviewing the applications, the Constitutional Court concluded that the forced school transfers indeed constituted a clear violation of the right to education guaranteed under Article 42. In its reasoned judgment, the supreme court highlighted a fundamental constitutional principle: restrictions placed upon fundamental rights and freedoms must be clearly delineated by primary parliamentary legislation (kanun) rather than reliance on executive regulations (yönetmelik).
The court emphasized that the disciplinary sanctions enforced against the students were grounded exclusively in executive regulations issued by the Ministry of National Education. The legal system lacked a sufficiently detailed, explicit statutory law enacted by parliament that defined the specific infractions and corresponding penalties applicable to secondary school students. The Constitutional Court noted that under the principle of legality, citizens—including students—must be able to foresee which specific actions constitute punishable offenses and what precise statutory sanctions those actions entail.
To remedy the violation, the Constitutional Court ordered that the case files be remanded back to the relevant local administrative courts for retrials aimed at eliminating the consequences of the rights violations. Furthermore, the court awarded 50,000 Turkish Liras in non-pecuniary damages to each of the two students to compensate for the moral distress suffered as a result of the unlawful administrative measures.
Legal experts note that while this ruling does not completely strip educational authorities of their power to maintain school discipline, it firmly establishes that any disciplinary action impacting a student’s constitutional right to education must be anchored in primary legislative statutes. This ruling establishes a powerful, favorable precedent for other students across the country who have faced forced school transfers or similar disciplinary measures executed under secondary administrative regulations.

Insurance Start Dates and Judicial Reasoning
The second major decision rendered by the Constitutional Court focuses on the right to a fair trial, specifically emphasizing the duty of lower courts to provide reasoned judgments when adjudicating complex social security and employment disputes.
The case was brought before the constitutional tribunal by applicant Kadriye Şendir, who had filed a lawsuit seeking judicial recognition of her 1989 employment activity as the official start date for her social security coverage. The determination of an initial insurance registration date is of paramount importance under Turkish labor and social security law, as it directly dictates retirement eligibility criteria, required premium payment days, and age thresholds for pension benefits.
During the lower court proceedings, Şendir presented established precedent rulings issued by the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay)—the highest court of appeals for civil and criminal matters in Turkey—which supported her legal position regarding the evaluation of past service records. However, the trial court rejected her lawsuit without addressing, evaluating, or explaining why the specific Court of Cassation precedents cited in her defense were not applicable to her case.
Upon reviewing the individual application, the Constitutional Court held that the trial court’s failure to address material arguments and relevant legal precedents constituted a direct violation of the right to a fair trial, which is protected under Article 36 of the Turkish Constitution.
The Constitutional Court stressed that procedural fairness requires judicial bodies to thoroughly evaluate key evidence and legal arguments presented by litigants. When a party relies on established high-court jurisprudence that directly bears on the outcome of a case, trial courts are obligated to provide a clear legal rationale if they choose to depart from or disregard those precedents.

By failing to provide a reasoned explanation for ignoring the relevant Court of Cassation rulings, the lower court deprived the applicant of a fair hearing and undermined judicial predictability. The decision underscores a crucial legal safeguard for individuals seeking to establish past work records (hizmet tespiti), reinforcing the requirement that trial courts must systematically address higher court precedents in their final judgments.
Unpaid Civil Servant Salaries and Access to Justice
The third ruling published by the supreme court addresses the constitutional right of access to a court in the context of administrative law, public finance, and long-standing wage disputes involving municipal employees.
The underlying dispute originated in the district of Haymana, located in the Ankara province. Civil servants working for the former Çalış Municipality faced years of non-payment, accumulating substantial unpaid salary balances and accrued interest between 2002 and 2014. Following major local government administrative reorganizations, the municipal entity of Çalış was formally dissolved, and its legal personality was abolished. Under the relevant statutory provisions governing municipal mergers and closures, all financial assets, liabilities, and legal obligations of the defunct municipality were officially transferred to the central Haymana Municipality.
In 2014, the affected public servants initiated formal legal enforcement proceedings and legal actions to collect their unpaid earnings from the successor municipality. However, when the cases reached the administrative courts, the judges dismissed the lawsuits outright, ruling that the claims were time-barred due to the expiration of the statutory period of limitations (zamanaşımı).
The public servants filed individual applications with the Constitutional Court, arguing that the unexpected interpretation of the statute of limitations by the lower courts effectively blocked them from recovering earned income and denied them access to judicial relief.

In its comprehensive evaluation, the Constitutional Court ruled that the administrative courts’ interpretation regarding the start date of the statutory limitation period was unforeseeable and imposed an excessive, unreasonable burden on the applicants. The tribunal declared that such a rigid and unpredictable legal interpretation breached the applicants’ right of access to court, an essential element of the constitutional right to legal remedies.
The Constitutional Court observed that legal rules governing time limits for filing lawsuits must be interpreted in a predictable manner that preserves legal certainty while ensuring that citizens are not arbitrarily deprived of the opportunity to seek judicial enforcement of legitimate public claims. By calculating the prescription period in a manner that rendered the recovery of back pay practically impossible, the lower courts placed an unconstitutional barrier between the public servants and the justice system.
Consequently, the Constitutional Court ordered the case files to be remitted to four separate administrative courts in Ankara for retrials, instructing the lower benches to re-evaluate the wage claims in light of the constitutional standards articulated in the judgment. Although the Constitutional Court rejected the applicants’ specific demands for direct pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages, the decision clears the way for the civil servants to have their substantive wage claims fully re-examined on the merits without being blocked by unforeseeable procedural time-bars.
Through this ruling, the Constitutional Court reiterated that public authorities and administrative tribunals must adhere to principles of legal certainty and predictability, ensuring that administrative restructurings and procedural rules do not undermine the constitutional right of public employees to claim earned compensation through the courts.
